Electricity and Magnetism II Spring 2018
- Instructor: Prof. Danny Caballero
- Class Meetings: MWF 1:50 PM - 2:40 PM (1300 BPS)
- Instructor: firstname.lastname@example.org, cell: (517) 420-5330, office: 1310-A BPS
- Office hrs: Open door policy. I enjoy visiting and talking with you about physics.
- Web page: dannycab.github.io/phy482msu_s2018/
Piazza Discussion Forum
This term we will be using Piazza for class discussion. The system is highly catered to getting you help fast and efficiently from classmates and myself. Rather than emailing questions to the teaching staff, I encourage you to post your questions on Piazza. Find our class page at: https://piazza.com/msu/spring2018/phy482/home
Physics 482, Electricity and Magnetism 2, is the second semester of our two-semester sequence of junior-level classical electromagnetism.
For most of you, 482 is an elective course that you are taking to advance your knowledge of electromagnetism. As such, this course is designed under several different principles than a standard course. Below, I provide those principles and their rationale.
- 482 should help you learn the central tenets of Electromagnetism
- This course provides the conclusion of the story started in 481. In 481, we were concerned with static charges and steady currents, but in 482, we broaden our scope to allow distributions and thus fields to change with time. This course should help you see how all the different aspects of Electromagnetism are connected together and how it is that Classical Electromagnetism is a coherent theory. Because Electromagnetism is such a broad topic, we will cover the basic in class and you will research advanced topics and share them with your class mates. At the end of the semester, we will bring it all together.
- 482 should be a celebration of your knowledge
- For most of you, this course concludes your study of physics at MSU. What you have achieved in the last four years should be celebrated and enjoyed. This course will provide ample opportunities for you to share what things you know and what things you are learning with me and with each other.
- 482 should give you opportunities to engage in professional practice
- As you start towards your professional career, it’s important to learn what professional scientists do. You have probably already begun this work in advanced lab and research projects that you have worked on. We will continue developing your professional skills in this course through the use of course projects in lieu of exams.
- 482 will illustrate that we can learn from each other
- Even though I’ve been learning physics for almost 20 years, I don’t know everything. I am excited to learn from you and I hope that you are excited to learn from me and each other.
- J.D. Griffiths. Introduction to Electromagnetism, 4th Edition (Pearson; 2012). This book is pedagogically excellent and is my favorite undergrad textbook of them all! There are other editions that might be less expensive, and they can be substituted. But reading assignments will come from the 4th edition, which may have some different content.
Reading is an essential part of 482! Reading the text before class is very important. Lecture is to clarify your understanding, to help you make sense of the material. I will assume you have done the required readings in advance! Griffiths is one of the best (and most readable) texts I know of - it will make a huge difference if you spend the time and effort to carefully read and follow the text. The calendar has the details on reading assignments, in-class, activites, and homework.
Classroom Etiquette: Please turn off all cell phones and pagers when entering any classroom. Private chatter during lecture can be distracting to your classmates, but it is perfectly OK to interrupt the lecture by yelling “Question!” Questions in lecture are always good, and are strongly encouraged!
In-Class Activities: We will also use a variety of in-class activities and worksheets that help you construct an understanding of a particular topic or concept. These will not be collected or graded, but we will discuss the solutions in class. Your participation in them will a small percentage of extra credit (up to 5% on your homework/exam average, whichever helps you more).
There will be a homework due every Friday by 5pm. Late homework can’t be accepted once solutions are posted - but, your lowest score will be dropped. Homework is exceedingly important for developing an understanding of the course material, not to mention building skills in complex physical and mathematical problem solving. They will require considerable time and personal effort this term! Your lowest homework grade will be dropped.
There are four kinds of homework problems in this class:
Standard Homework Problems: These are regular back-of-the-book type homework problems that involve derivations, calculations, figures, and graphs. If you took 481, there will be fewer of these in 482. As we have no assigned grader, each question will be coarsely graded for “completion”:
- 10 pts. complete
- 8 pts. right idea, but incomplete
- 4 pts. relatively incomplete
- 0 pts. not turned in
Computational Homework Problems: There will be some use of computation in this course on homework problems. I will encourage and support the use of Python (through Jupyter notebooks). You do not need any computational experience for this course as you will learn some fundamentals early on and keep using them throughout the course. You are welcome to use any environment of your choosing (e.g., Octave/MATLAB, Mathematica, C++), but I will only provide support for Python. Python is in use across the sciences, but it is becoming much used in physics, so learning it will serve you well in your future work. I suggest downloading the Anaconda distribution of Python as it comes with all the packages you will need to get up and running with Jupyter notebooks. These will be graded on the same 10-8-4-0 scale as standard homework problems. Here are instructions for installing Jupyter Notebooks.
Project Homework Problems: These are homework problems to support your working towards completing your individual and paired projects (see below). Projects are difficult to complete, so having some regular check-ins on how those projects are going, setting milestones to complete, and producing a semi-complete piece of a project are all important aspects of research! These homework problems are meant to help you make that progress each week. They count twice as much as normal homework problems, but follow a similar grading scale:
- 20 pts. complete
- 16 pts. right idea, but incomplete
- 8 pts. relatively incomplete
- 0 pts. not turned in
You will be given detailed feedback on these project homework problems as you are working on bigger projects throughout this class. You should read and be responsive to this feedback as it will help you develop a strong project.
Self-reflection Homework Problems: These are homework problems that ask you to evaluate your progress on your projects and how you and your partner are working together. Evaluating how well you understand something and what you need to do to move forward is a hard thing to learn. So is working on a team (or with a partner). These homework problems are meant to help you do both and get feedback from me on how things are going. These problems are graded out of 10 points like regular homework problems on the same 10-8-4-0 scale. You will also be given detailed feedback on these homework problems.
I strongly encourage collaboration, an essential skill in science and engineering (and highly valued by employers!) Social interactions are critical to scientists’ success – most good ideas grow out of discussions with colleagues, and essentially all physicists work as part of a group. Find partners and work on homework together. However, it is also important that you OWN the material. I strongly suggest you start homework by yourself (and that means really making an extended effort on every problem). Then work with a group, and finally, finish up on your own – write up your own work, in your own way. There will also be time for peer discussion during classes – as you work together, try to help your partners get over confusions, listen to them, ask each other questions, critique, teach each other. You will learn a lot this way! For all assignments, the work you turn in must in the end be your own: in your own words, reflecting your own understanding. (If, at any time, for any reason, you feel disadvantaged or isolated, contact me and I can discretely try to help arrange study groups.)
Times listed at the top of the syllabus) Help sessions/office hours are to facilitate your learning. We encourage attendance - plan on working in small groups, our role will be as learning coaches. The sessions are homework-centric, but we will not be explicitly telling anyone how to do the homework (how would that help you learn?) I strongly encourage you to start all problems on your own. If you come to help sessions “cold”, the value of homework to you will be greatly reduced.
Every other Friday, we will have a short, in-class quiz that covers the material discussed in the previous two weeks. The quiz will take the form of a typical exam-style question – more straight-forward than your homework questions with not much substantive calculations. I will inform you of the type and topic of the in-class quiz on the Friday prior to the quiz, so you will have a week to prepare should you want. There will seven of these quizzes. Your lowest quiz grade will be dropped.
In lieu of examinations, which are not at all representative of professional physics practice, you will produce two projects.
The first project is an individual research project and is meant to mimic the kind of literature review that is needed to understand a topic that is new to you. In a nutshell, you will select a topic of active research in electromagnetism, read several journal articles pertaining to the topic, and write a 3-4 page summary with references about the topic. You will be working to answer the following questions in your paper:
- What is the phenomenon and why is it interesting?
- What the relevant electrodynamic models that are used to make sense of this phenomenon?
- What are the assumptions that go into these models?
- What mathematical models and mathematical tools are used to make predictions?
- What are some of the major predictions?
- What experimental work has gone into validating these predictions?
- What the challenges in connecting the experimental and theoretical predictions?
There will be seven homework questions that help you develop your individual project. Having deadlines and milestones for such a project is important, so that you don’t get behind. Here’s a preliminary listing of the homework questions that will appear (note these are subject to change!):
- Homework 1 (What is interesting?) - Define your phenomenon; what is it? Why is it interesting to you? What are a few papers that you can use to start your background research (give actual references). 2-3 paragraphs along with a listing of at least 4 relevant journal articles.
- Homework 2 (Towards an annotated bibliography I) - Summarize 2 of the 4 relevant journal articles. What do they say about your phenomenon? How are the theoretical models constructed? What are the predictions and implications? 2-3 paragraphs per article.
- Homework 3 (Towards an annotated bibliography II)- Summarize 2 more relevant journal articles (can be the remaining 2 or 2 new ones if the direction of your research has changed). What do they say about your phenomenon? How are the theoretical models constructed? What are the predictions and implications? 2-3 paragraphs per article.
- Homework 4 (Building your paper I) - Summarize your background research so far (3-4 paragraphs on what you have learned so far) with references. What are people saying about this phenomenon? What are the relevant models? How are the models described?
- Homework 5 (Building your paper II) - Summarize the models used to describe your phenomenon (3-4 more paragraphs on what you have learned so far) with references. What are the predictions of these models? What mathematical tools are used to make these predictions?
- Homework 6 (Building your paper III) - Summarize the experimental work that validates the theoretical predictions (3-4 more paragraphs on what you have learned so far). What are the difficulties or successes connecting theory and experiment?
- Homework 7 (Constructing an abstract) - Summarize your entire paper in a single paragraph - You are writing an abstract. It should be self-contained and describe the entire paper in just a few sentences.
After Homework 7 (Fri. Mar 2), your paper is due. It should be 3-4 pages long not counting figures, equations, and references! It should fully describe all the aspects of the phenomenon that are being modeled including how the phenomenon is modeled, what predictions/implications they are, how it is connected to experiments, and what limitations there are in the modeling of it. There should be about 6-10 references to articles appearing in your paper. You have been continually reading about the topic, right?
Grading the individual project
A rubric for the individual project appears here. Notice that the rubric emphasizes several aspects of the paper with different weights. Each category will be scored on the following scale (4.0, 3.5, 3.0, 2.0, 0.0) and then averaged together using the weights for each category. Your final grade will be this averaged score converted to a 100 point scale.
The second project can (but doesn’t have to) build on this first project. It is a team project that you will complete with a partner. It is meant to mimic the common practice of poster preparation and presentation. In a nutshell, you will conduct an original modeling project where you analytically and computationally model some E&M phenomenon of your choosing, prepare a poster of the project, and present it to your classmates and me. In working on this project, you will be trying to answer the following questions:
- What is the area of E&M that you are doing research on?
- What are the questions that you are trying to answer about this area?
- What theoretical models can be used to answer those questions?
- What analytical and computational work did you do to answer those questions?
- What were the resulting predictions that your work produced?
- What are the limitations of what you have done? What are some remaining open questions?
- What did each member of your pair contribute?
There will be six homework questions (10 if you count the 4 self-reflection homework questions) to help your team develop your poster project, Here is a preliminary listing of the homework questions that will appear (note that these are subject to change!):
- Homework 8 - What are you and your partner proposing to do? What area of E&M will you be conducting original calculations for? What source material are you drawing from? What has been done so far and what are you going to do? It’s ok if it’s a solved problem, but you will need to reproduce what has been done and extend it beyond what your reference material offers.
- Homework 9 - What is the plan for the next 5 weeks? How do you intend to structure the work? Explain the details of what will be done and who will be doing what. I expect 2-3 paragraphs describing the work and a detailed timeline.
- Homework 10 - Provide a detailed explanation of the models and theoretical calculations needed to set up your work. This should be presented as a “graphic” that would appear in a poster under “background or model.” There will also be a self-reflection homework problem - Who did what? What questions do you need to answer to continue to move forward? What help do you need from me or others?
- Homework 11 - There should be some sample calculations and figures produced by your code. This can be a notebook (Mathematica; Jupyter; etc.), but the work needs to be explained inline (i.e., what are you doing and why?). This is the work that is the meat of your original contribution. It need not be complete yet. There will also be a self-reflection homework problem - Who did what? What questions were you able to answer last week? What questions do you need to answer to continue to move forward? What help do you need from me or others?
- Homework 12 - At this point, you should produce draft figures for poster with captions. You should have pressed onward with your calculations and produced appropriate figures for your poster with captions. The “graphic” and caption should be turned in. These need not be complete in the sense that you should continue working on your calculations and models until the poster is turned in. There will also be a self-reflection homework problem - Who did what? What questions were you able to answer last week? What questions do you need to answer to continue to move forward? What help do you need from me or others?
- Homework 13 - Finally, you should produce an abstract for your poster. You should have a self-contained paragraph on what you will present in your poster. There will also be a self-reflection homework problem - Who did what? What questions were you able to answer last week? What questions do you need to answer to continue to move forward? What help do you need from me or others?
After Homework 13 (Mon. Apr. 30 - during our final exam period), your poster is due. You and your teammate will present your poster to your classmates and myself. Your poster and presentation will be graded by me. But, you will also be given evaluation sheets for your classmates’ posters, which I’ll ask that you share with them (anonymously if you like). Your participation in the evaluation of your classmates’ posters counts towards your grade on your poster. There will also be a self-reflection/evaluation component to this assignment that asks you: Who did what? What did you learn? What did you want to learn more about? What was straight-forward? What was more difficult? Completion of this self-reflection/evaluation will also count towards the overall grade on your poster.
Grading the pair project
A rubric for the individual project appears here. Notice that the rubric emphasizes several aspects of the poster with different weights. Each category will be scored on the following scale (4.0, 3.5, 3.0, 2.0, 0.0) and then averaged together using the weights for each category. Your final grade will be this averaged score converted to a 100 point scale.
|Activity||Date||Percent of Grade|
|Homework (14 total; 1 dropped)||Due Mon at start of class||40%|
|In-Class Quizzes (7 total; 1 dropped)||Every other Friday||20%|
|Individual Project||Fri Mar 2||20%|
|Pair Project||Mon Apr 30||20%|
Comments on preparation:
Physics 482 covers material you might have seen before (Many of the topics stem from PHY 184/294H material) but at a higher level of conceptual and mathematical sophistication.
Therefore you should expect:
- a large amount of material covered quickly.
- no recitations, and few examples covered in lecture. Most homework problems are not similar to examples from class.
- long, hard homework problems that usually cannot be completed by one individual alone.
- challenging projects.
Physics 482 is a challenging, upper‐division physics course. Unlike more introductory courses, you are fully responsible for your own learning. In particular, you control the pace of the course by asking questions in class. I tend to speak quickly, and questions are important to slow down the lecture. This means that if you don’t understand something, it is your responsibility to ask questions. Attending class and the homework help sessions gives you an opportunity to ask questions. I am here to help you as much as possible, but I need your questions to know what you don’t understand.
Physics 482 covers some of the most important physics and mathematical methods in the field. Your reward for the hard work and effort will be learning important and elegant material that you will use over and over as a physics major. Here is what I have experienced, and heard from other faculty teaching upper division physics in the past:
- most students reported spending a minimum of 10 hours per week on the homework (!!)
- students who didn’t attend the homework help sessions often did poorly in the class.
- students reported learning a tremendous amount in this class.
The course topics that we will cover in Physics 482 are among the greatest intellectual achievements of humans. Don’t be surprised if you have to think hard and work hard to master the material.
Handling Emergency Situations
In the event of an emergency arising within the classroom, Prof. Caballero will notify you of what actions that may be required to ensure your safety. It is the responsibility of each student to understand the evacuation, “shelter-in-place,” and “secure-in-place” guidelines posted in each facility and to act in a safe manner. You are allowed to maintain cellular devices in a silent mode during this course, in order to receive emergency SMS text, phone or email messages distributed by the university. When anyone receives such a notification or observes an emergency situation, they should immediately bring it to the attention of Prof. Caballero in a way that causes the least disruption. If an evacuation is ordered, please ensure that you do it in a safe manner and facilitate those around you that may not otherwise be able to safely leave. When these orders are given, you do have the right as a member of this community to follow that order. Also, if a shelter-in-place or secure-in-place is ordered, please seek areas of refuge that are safe depending on the emergency encountered and provide assistance if it is advisable to do so.